Alan Bear receives maximum sentence

Alan Bear pleaded guilty to misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter today, and received the maximum sentence of 1 year in jail and 3 years probation in addition to roughly $5000 in fines.

Five letters had been submitted in advance of the sentencing. Several members of Greg's family spoke about the loss of their loved one, and the facts in the case. The testimony from Lisa Hoover, Greg's widow, was particularly poignant. "He was just riding his bike home as he always did. He didn't make it home," she said several times, and described the depth of her loss and the lack of remorse on the part of Mr. Bear.

About 25 to 30 attendees were family and friends of Ms. Hoover, or members of the bicycling community.

Mr. Bear apologized for the first time for his part in the collision that took place over one year ago, and repeatd the same story of replacing a drink in the cupholder distracting him, and trying to swerve right around Greg because there was a vehical to his left.

Bear also stated that he didn't think bicycles belonged on the freeway. In her response to the accused's statement, the people's attorney highlighted Bear's placing blame on the victim for doing something that is perfectly legal.

The judge remarked concern over Bear's lying at the scene of the collision as "problematic" before he assigned the maximum sentence. However, the court has no jurisdiction over driver's license suspension. That responsibility rests with the DMV. The court will revisit the issue in October once they receive information from the DMV on administrative decisions with regard Bear's driving privileges.

Thanks to those who were able to write letters to the judge and attend hearings, and to the deputy DA on the case (The last in a long line. I didn't get her name) for calling Bear on his statement regarding cyclists rights to use the freeway. It's disappointing that this case couldn't be pursued as felony manslaughter with gross negligence, but the final result and maximum sentence with the lesser charge certainly provide some modicum of justice and closure for Greg's family and for the wider bicycling community.

Addendum: Here is an email from Rick Knapp of the humboldt Bay Bicycle Commuters Association, who has done and excellent job closely following the case to support a just conclusion:

While many of you were there today, some of you weren't, so here in a nutshell is what happened:
Bear pleaded guilty to all charges. The judge allowed only family and eye witnesses to testify regarding sentencing. Some powerful words were spoken by Lisa Hoover (Spouse); Jim Jennings (Father); Terry Bissell (Step Mother); Becky Perry (Eye Witness); and Rick Knapp (reading a letter from Greg's brother, Packard). The Judge also acknowledged the many letters he had received (probably about 20 in total).
Bear responded, did his best to drum up some tears, tried to show remorse, then drove in the final nail for us by blaming the victim for being on a freeway with a bike in the first place.
Judge Watson then levied about the harshest penalties he could for a misdemeanor manslaughter charge--ONE YEAR JAIL TIME, FOLLOWED BY THREE YEARS PROBATION. In addition he levied about $5,000 in fines. He will also be losing his driving license for some unspecified time for these charges and the fact that he was recently stopped for driving with a suspended license and no proof of insurance.
So, in the end, even though we believed he should have been charged with a felony (with gross negligence), we got the best sentence we could hope for given the reduced charges. Our efforts were aided by the newly assigned Deputy D. A., Elan Firpo. She is the first person from the D. A.'s office who has stepped up to the plate to push for justice in this case. Others, including Paul Gallegos did little except to prolong the agony. Gallegos had never pursued the maximum sentence, the one year jail time. He gave us little hope for any jail time, had even attempted an earlier plea bargain for a felony with NO JAIL TIME.
There were nearly 30 people in attendance supporting the family and justice today. We were all happy to go away with a little good news this one time.
Thanks for all the help from all of you along the way.
Sincerely,
Rick Knapp

Addendum II: Here's the Time-Standard Coverage.

Trackback URL for this post:

http://www.green-wheels.org/trackback/708

About Chris Rall